Advertisement
Sections
Watch: Critics reveal how they decide how many stars a film should get
In the latest episode of Film Stripped, three film critics debate the merits and demerits of adding star ratings to reviews.

Have you ever been disappointed by a two star rating given to your favorite Salman Khan film? Does it anger you when a critic gives a half star rating to a popular film and five stars to an obscure one? Well then, this video will give you an explanation for the average movie critic's rating process. In the latest episode of Film Stripped with the Entertainment Editor of CNN IBN Rajeev Masand, you'll find that most critics are wary of adding stars to their reviews. Chances are that you just might understand the motivations of film critics who've so often frustrated you.In the episode, Masand, along with Journalist Mihir Fadnavis and Entertainment Editor of Firstpost, Deepanjana Pal sit down to debate the merits of adding star ratings to a film review. Pal and Fadnavis make a compelling argument for doing away with the system of star ratings, arguing that it stops the reader from reading the rest of the review. They also argue that star ratings undermine the art of review writing and limit the subjectivity of a review.[caption id="attachment_1706169" align="alignleft" width="380"]
Courtesy: Youtube[/caption]For instance, critics may give a four star rating to a Rajkumar Hirani comedy and and a three star rating to the latest Vishal Bharadwaj film. This does not mean that the comedy is a better film, it only shows that the film is well made for the genre that it belongs to.They also discuss the difficulty of grading a film based on numbers given that movies are an art form and not exam papers. For these critic, giving a rating to the film is often a spur of the moment decision, one that they might even regret later.Ideally, most critics would like to avoid giving star ratings to a film. Fadnavis puts it simply, "It's unfair to the film, it's unfair to the filmmaker, it's unfair to the audience and it's unfair to the reviewer". Unfortunately, for audiences who demand short verdicts due to paucity of time, the humble star rating is the easiest way to judge the quality of the film. You can watch the video here:
Courtesy: Youtube[/caption]For instance, critics may give a four star rating to a Rajkumar Hirani comedy and and a three star rating to the latest Vishal Bharadwaj film. This does not mean that the comedy is a better film, it only shows that the film is well made for the genre that it belongs to.They also discuss the difficulty of grading a film based on numbers given that movies are an art form and not exam papers. For these critic, giving a rating to the film is often a spur of the moment decision, one that they might even regret later.Ideally, most critics would like to avoid giving star ratings to a film. Fadnavis puts it simply, "It's unfair to the film, it's unfair to the filmmaker, it's unfair to the audience and it's unfair to the reviewer". Unfortunately, for audiences who demand short verdicts due to paucity of time, the humble star rating is the easiest way to judge the quality of the film. You can watch the video here:First Published:Sep 10, 2014, 16:41:16 IST
Advertisement
Advertisement

Nargis Fakhri rings in New Year's with rumoured boyfriend Tony Beig and ex-boyfriend Uday Chopra, photo goes viral
Before Tony, Nargis was in a relationship with Uday Chopra. In a conversation with ETimes, the Main Tera Hero actress revealed that she dated Uday for five years, adding he was the most beautiful human she met in India
Karan Johar drops selfie with Rani Mukerji and a message for trolls as 2024 begins
In the picture, Karan posed for a selfie with Rani Mukerji. The duo twinned in black. He accompanied the picture with a text that read "Ami Rani…2024"
WATCH: Ira Khan And Nupur Shikhare's wedding festivities begin at Aamir Khan’s Mumbai home
Nupur Shikhare made a romantic proposal to Ira Khan during a sports event. He went down on one knee to present the love of his life with a ring
'Three months of hell': Sonam Kapoor on husband Anand Ahuja's illness which 'no doctor could diagnose'
Sonam went on to reflect on how she balanced supporting her husband in his work while trying to spend time with her precious family and incredible friends and called it the most tough, amazing, fulfilling and enriching year
Prakash Raj summoned by Enforcement Directorate in a 100-crore ponzi & fraud case, actor reacts
The investigation pertains to a case against Pranav Jewellers, a partnership firm based in Tiruchirapalli, whom the ED raided on November 20 and claimed to have seized "unexplained" cash of Rs 23.70 lakh and some gold jewellery
Advertisement
Advertisement
