Why Arundhati Roy's memoir is the perfect Mother's Day read

Mothers forgive endlessly, love unconditionally, and exist primarily as emotional scaffolding for their children’s lives. Arundhati Roy has never been interested in polishing anything.

In Mother Mary Comes to Me, motherhood arrives not as a halo but as a storm system — unpredictable, powerful, occasionally destructive, and impossible to ignore. It is precisely this refusal to sentimentalise motherhood that makes Roy’s memoir the perfect book to read today.

The mother who refused to fit the mould

At the centre of the memoir is Roy’s mother, Mary Roy, a woman whose life resists the tidy narratives we like to attach to maternal figures.

To the outside world, Mary Roy appears almost mythic. She was the founder of a school in Kerala that grew into an institution with a waiting list at birth. More importantly, she was the petitioner in a landmark Supreme Court case that overturned the discriminatory Travancore Christian Succession Act of 1916. The judgement, delivered in 1986, granted Syrian Christian women equal inheritance rights and remains one of the most significant feminist victories in Indian legal history.

More from Lifestyle

It is the kind of achievement that easily earns someone a place in history books. History books, however, rarely mention what happens inside the home. Roy’s memoir insists on looking there.

In her telling, Mary Roy is formidable and brilliant, but also volatile and deeply contradictory. She could nurture intellectual curiosity while simultaneously instilling fear. She could challenge patriarchy in courtrooms while exercising an almost tyrannical authority within her own household.

This duality sits at the heart of the memoir — and at the heart of motherhood itself.

The myth of the perfect mother

Modern culture places mothers on an impossible pedestal. They are expected to be both endlessly loving and morally flawless, their identities collapsing entirely into their children’s well-being.

Roy dismantles this myth with quiet precision.

In Mother Mary Comes to Me, motherhood is not a moral category. It is simply another human condition—messy, flawed, and shaped by the same contradictions that govern the rest of life.

Mary Roy is capable of immense generosity and startling cruelty. She reads Shakespeare and Kipling to her children but disciplines them with frightening severity. She is fiercely protective and emotionally distant at the same time. The effect is disorienting, but also strangely liberating.

Once the myth of the perfect mother collapses, something more honest can take its place: the recognition that mothers, like their children, are still in the process of becoming.

Loving someone you cannot fully understand

Roy’s relationship with her mother is built on this unstable ground. Love, in the memoir, is rarely straightforward. It is tangled with resentment, admiration, guilt, and longing. Roy recalls leaving home at sixteen, not out of a lack of love but in order to preserve it. Staying, she states, might have destroyed their relationship entirely.

It is a sentiment many readers will recognise but rarely see articulated with such clarity: sometimes distance is the only way to continue loving someone.

The memoir repeatedly returns to this paradox. Roy admires her mother’s courage and intellect, yet struggles with the emotional scars of their upbringing. She recognises the historical significance of Mary Roy’s feminist battles while still grappling with the private consequences of living under such a formidable personality.

In doing so, Roy reveals a difficult truth about motherhood: the qualities that allow someone to challenge the world are often the same qualities that make them difficult to live with.

When the child becomes the storyteller

There is another reason this memoir feels particularly timely.

Many of us reach a moment in adulthood when we begin to see our parents differently — not as the towering figures of childhood but as complicated individuals shaped by their own fears, ambitions, and wounds. Roy writes from precisely this vantage point.

The child who once experienced her mother as an overwhelming force now looks back with the curiosity of a storyteller. The memoir does not attempt to resolve the contradictions it uncovers. Instead, it lingers within them, allowing readers to witness the slow and often uncomfortable process of understanding one’s parents as human beings.

Reading Roy’s account can feel like overhearing a conversation many adults have privately with themselves: Who were our parents before we arrived? What parts of their lives remain inaccessible to us? And how do we reconcile the people who raised us with the people they truly were?

Why this book matters now

In a cultural moment saturated with idealised motherhood — from social media to advertising, Roy’s memoir offers something far rarer: honesty.

Mother Mary Comes to Me refuses to present motherhood as purely nurturing or purely oppressive. Instead, it portrays it as a relationship capable of containing both love and damage simultaneously.

This honesty extends beyond Roy’s personal story. By situating her mother’s life within the social constraints of mid-twentieth-century India, the memoir also reveals how motherhood itself is shaped by larger political and cultural forces. Mary Roy’s struggles were not only personal but structural, rooted in laws and traditions that limited women’s autonomy. Understanding this context does not excuse her contradictions, but it does illuminate them.

Perhaps that is the most generous act the memoir performs: it allows readers to hold complexity without demanding resolution. By the time the memoir closes, Roy has not solved the riddle of her mother. The contradictions remain stubbornly intact, and that is the point.

Motherhood, like memory, resists neat conclusions. It is built from fragments, moments of tenderness, moments of anger, moments of confusion that only gain meaning years later.