Advertisement
Sections
India (hearts) Mary Kom. But do we deserve her?
There's something patronising about all this "Never mind, we still love you, Mary Kom" gush. India, thou over-compensateth too much as if to say Hail Mary, full of grace, grant us forgiveness for all those chinky jokes.

There is indeed something about Mary.But the “oh never mind, we still love you, Mary” adulation that is sloshing around the media after Mary Kom lost her Olympics semi-final says something more about the rest of us than it does about Magnificent Mary.It says that as a country we know full well that we have treated the seven sisters of the north-east abysmally. But we are hoping our new-found ardour for Mary Kom will grant us absolution.From hardly knowing who Mary Kom was a few months ago, now we have swung to the other extreme of over-compensation. Mary Kom is everywhere as if to prove hum kissise Kom nahin.In her, India has finally found a story about Manipur in particular, and the north east in general, that is not about insurgency, HIV, drugs, floods or AFSPA. Her own state's Irom Sharmila really came into the national spotlight because Anna Hazare was fasting in Jantar Mantar though Sharmila has been refusing food for over a decade. Even now I’d bet most of us have only the vaguest idea why she fasts.But India has seized on the Mary Kom story with enormous relief because there is guilt about the fact that most of us don’t know where Manipur is relative to Mizoram on the map. In her pluck we find a feel-good story that lets us off the hook.[caption id="attachment_411998" align="alignleft" width="380"]
Mary Kom’s victory will not mean Manipur or its sister states will get better treatment from New Delhi. Reuters[/caption]Hail Mary, full of grace, grant us forgiveness for all those chinky jokes. Forgive us, because though now you are all over the covers of magazines, and your sister and sister-in-law are having microphones thrust in their faces, and newspaper correspondents are trekking over to your house in Manipur to watch the match with your family, a few months ago we didn’t really care anything about you or your against-all-odds boxing career.In the insightful profile Rahul Bhattacharya did about her for Intelligent Life, Kom says simply, “We are Indian. Ya, the face is different. But heart is Indian.” But until this shining Olympic moment her country didn’t think the same. They just saw the face and dismissed it as “other”.And sadly, I’d wager that’s how it will be despite this medal. Mary Kom’s victory might inspire other girls to take up boxing. Her boxing school might be flooded with applicants. But the Mizo shopgirl in a mall in Gurgaon will still suffer her share of “chinky” jokes and girls who look like Mary Kom won’t have an easier time renting flats. "It is not correct to say that students of northeast states are more vulnerable as compared to students from other regions," P Chidambaram told the Rajya Sabha. But his fellow UPA minister Agatha Sangma retorted, “South is very different from North, but no south Indian in Delhi would be made to feel he does not look Indian.”Mary Kom’s victory will not mean Manipur or its sister states will get better treatment from New Delhi. It will probably not even mean more electricity for a state where Kom’s family had to get a generator to make sure they would be able to watch her big match. As CNN-IBN correspondent Arijit Sen tweeted after the big electricity blackout: I’ve been asked to check if Manipur’s power situation is normal. Yes at 1 hour of electricity every day it’s getting its normal quota.The rise of Mary Kom and Devendro Singh will lead to colourful stories about what’s it about Manipuris and boxing. 1998 Asian Games hero Dingko Singh told The Telegraph “That’s because, by nature, we’re aggressive… gussa aa jata hai.” He was joking but Manipur has plenty of reasons to be pissed about.The medal of Mary Kom could have been a way to talk about all of this. But instead it becomes the fig-leaf that covers it all up, so we don’t have to talk about anything else other than patronisingly pat her on the back and say, “Well done, Mary, mother of twins. We know how hard it is to be super Mom and super boxer. Aren't those kids cute! ”Her medal is being embraced as a triumph for India. "I join the nation in congratulating boxer Mary Kom for winning the Olympic bronze medal in the 51kg women's boxing event. She showed great discipline and determination and has done India proud," Manmohan Singh Singh said in a statement. “But India will have nothing to do with her victory,” writes blogger Priyanka Nandy.On the contrary, she writes:
Mary Kom’s victory will not mean Manipur or its sister states will get better treatment from New Delhi. Reuters[/caption]Hail Mary, full of grace, grant us forgiveness for all those chinky jokes. Forgive us, because though now you are all over the covers of magazines, and your sister and sister-in-law are having microphones thrust in their faces, and newspaper correspondents are trekking over to your house in Manipur to watch the match with your family, a few months ago we didn’t really care anything about you or your against-all-odds boxing career.In the insightful profile Rahul Bhattacharya did about her for Intelligent Life, Kom says simply, “We are Indian. Ya, the face is different. But heart is Indian.” But until this shining Olympic moment her country didn’t think the same. They just saw the face and dismissed it as “other”.And sadly, I’d wager that’s how it will be despite this medal. Mary Kom’s victory might inspire other girls to take up boxing. Her boxing school might be flooded with applicants. But the Mizo shopgirl in a mall in Gurgaon will still suffer her share of “chinky” jokes and girls who look like Mary Kom won’t have an easier time renting flats. "It is not correct to say that students of northeast states are more vulnerable as compared to students from other regions," P Chidambaram told the Rajya Sabha. But his fellow UPA minister Agatha Sangma retorted, “South is very different from North, but no south Indian in Delhi would be made to feel he does not look Indian.”Mary Kom’s victory will not mean Manipur or its sister states will get better treatment from New Delhi. It will probably not even mean more electricity for a state where Kom’s family had to get a generator to make sure they would be able to watch her big match. As CNN-IBN correspondent Arijit Sen tweeted after the big electricity blackout: I’ve been asked to check if Manipur’s power situation is normal. Yes at 1 hour of electricity every day it’s getting its normal quota.The rise of Mary Kom and Devendro Singh will lead to colourful stories about what’s it about Manipuris and boxing. 1998 Asian Games hero Dingko Singh told The Telegraph “That’s because, by nature, we’re aggressive… gussa aa jata hai.” He was joking but Manipur has plenty of reasons to be pissed about.The medal of Mary Kom could have been a way to talk about all of this. But instead it becomes the fig-leaf that covers it all up, so we don’t have to talk about anything else other than patronisingly pat her on the back and say, “Well done, Mary, mother of twins. We know how hard it is to be super Mom and super boxer. Aren't those kids cute! ”Her medal is being embraced as a triumph for India. "I join the nation in congratulating boxer Mary Kom for winning the Olympic bronze medal in the 51kg women's boxing event. She showed great discipline and determination and has done India proud," Manmohan Singh Singh said in a statement. “But India will have nothing to do with her victory,” writes blogger Priyanka Nandy.On the contrary, she writes:If, however, she had quit the ring after the first year of boxing on a rice-and-vegetable diet, without proper shoes, clothes, equipment or coaches, India would have had everything to with it. The Indian state compels Mary to live a difficult life in a difficult terrain, without electricity, much personal security or enough food on the table, but with a surfeit of armed personnel who frequently use the locals as their personal entertainment.”Mary Kom deserves her medal many times over.But does India deserve Mary Kom?
First Published:Aug 09, 2012, 13:05:38 IST
Advertisement
Advertisement

Rahul Gandhi, Kharge lead protest near PM residence; Centre says Parliament discussion was offered
The developments come amid the continuing CJP-led agitation at Jantar Mantar, where protesters have vowed to continue their sit-in despite recent clashes with Delhi Police
2 min read
Parliament's Monsoon Session from July 20: Key bills, numbers game to dominate agenda
The Monsoon Session of Parliament will begin on July 20 and continue till August 13, with the government expected to push several key legislations, including constitutional amendment bills
2 min read
Major blow to Uddhav Thackeray as six Lok Sabha MPs join Shinde camp
In a major political setback for Shiv Sena (UBT) chief Uddhav Thackeray, six of the party's nine Lok Sabha MPs joined the Eknath Shinde-led Shiv Sena in Mumbai on Monday
2 min read
12 years and counting: NDA leaders felicitate PM Modi as he trumps Nehru's tenure record
Leaders of the National Democratic Alliance (NDA) on Wednesday felicitated Prime Minister Narendra Modi on completing 12 years in office and becoming India's longest-serving continuously elected Prime Minister
3 min read
‘Trust, progress and welfare’: PM Modi celebrates 12 years in office, highlights big policy moves
Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Tuesday marked 12 years in office. He described the period as one dedicated to "trust, development and public welfare" while highlighting key achievements of his government
3 min read
Advertisement
Advertisement
