Hand dryers vs paper towels: Which is more hygienic?

When it comes to drying your hands after washing them, the debate between paper towels and hand dryers has been going on for decades. Public toilets in airports, shopping centres, offices and restaurants often use one or the other, with advocates on both sides claiming theirs is the cleaner option.

The truth is that the most hygienic choice depends not just on the drying method, but also on how well you wash your hands in the first place and how the drying facilities are maintained.

Why drying your hands matters

Many people focus on washing their hands but overlook the importance of drying them properly. Wet hands transfer bacteria and viruses much more easily than dry ones. Studies have shown that microbes can spread more readily from damp skin to surfaces, making thorough drying an essential part of good hand hygiene.

More from Lifestyle

Whether you use paper towels or a hand dryer, completely drying your hands is more important than leaving the washroom with damp fingers.

The case for paper towels

Paper towels have long been considered the gold standard in healthcare settings. One reason is that they physically remove moisture along with some remaining bacteria from the skin. The friction created while rubbing hands with a paper towel may also help reduce the number of microbes left after washing.

Paper towels also allow users to avoid touching potentially contaminated surfaces. Many people use the towel to turn off taps or open the restroom door before throwing it away, reducing the chance of picking up germs immediately after washing.

Several reviews of scientific studies have concluded that paper towels generally result in lower levels of bacterial contamination on hands and surrounding surfaces compared with some types of electric hand dryers.

The concerns about hand dryers

Not all hand dryers are the same. Traditional warm-air dryers work by blowing heated air over the hands, while newer jet-air dryers use powerful streams of unheated air to remove water much more quickly.

The main concern with hand dryers is not that they create bacteria, but that they can move bacteria already present in the washroom air. High-speed air jets may disperse tiny droplets of water and microorganisms into the surrounding environment, especially if users have not washed their hands thoroughly.

Some laboratory studies have found that jet-air dryers can spread droplets farther than paper towels. However, many researchers point out that these studies often use exaggerated conditions, such as artificially high concentrations of harmless bacteria, which may not accurately reflect everyday public restroom use.

What do experts say?

Public health experts generally agree on one point: washing your hands correctly is far more important than the drying method.

Using soap and water for at least 20 seconds removes most germs before drying even begins. If hands are washed properly, the remaining difference between paper towels and hand dryers becomes much smaller.

That said, in hospitals and healthcare facilities, paper towels are often preferred because they minimise the potential for dispersing microbes in environments where vulnerable patients are present.

For everyday settings such as offices, schools and shopping centres, both methods are considered acceptable when properly maintained.

Hygiene depends on maintenance

A neglected paper towel dispenser or an unclean hand dryer can both become hygiene problems. Washrooms should be cleaned regularly, bins should be emptied frequently, and hand dryers should be maintained according to the manufacturer's recommendations.

Users also play an important role. Rushing through handwashing, skipping soap or leaving with wet hands can undermine the benefits of any drying method.

The verdict

If hygiene alone is the priority, current evidence slightly favours paper towels, particularly in healthcare environments where reducing the spread of germs is critical. They dry hands quickly, may remove additional bacteria through friction and are less likely to disperse microbes into the surrounding air.

However, for most healthy people using public washrooms, the difference is relatively small. Proper handwashing remains the single most effective way to prevent the spread of infectious diseases.

In the end, the cleanest hands come not from choosing paper towels over a hand dryer, but from washing thoroughly, drying completely and avoiding unnecessary contact with contaminated surfaces before leaving the restroom.